When the Parish of All Faith in St. Mary's County was created in 1692, the Parish Church at Huntersville was already built and named "All Faith." According to competent authority, the name "All Faith" was originally "Allfaiths," because in Resurrection Hundred it was the only building set aside for religious worship and all faiths used it.

All Faith Parish is fortunate in that most of its ancient records have been preserved. The first entry in these old records has to do with the establishment of the parish by the colonial legislature of Maryland, being number twelve of the Establishment.

Like many old churches, the original structure was built of logs. It was located on the site of the present building and was erected around 1655. This building was rebuilt in 1693 and finally replaced by the present colonial (Flemish bond) brick structure in 1767.

There have been three chapels of ease in All Faith Parish. The "Red Framed Church," located near Laurel Grove, was built in 1767 and was in ruins by 1830. The "Four-Mile Run Church," located near Sandy Bottom, became the first parish church of what is now St. Andrew's Parish. "St. Faith's Chapel," in Mechanicsville, was built in 1887 and was torn down in 1946.

The present All Faith Church was renovated in the 1800's, at which time stained glass windows, pews, and chancel furniture were gradually added. Following Hurricane Hazel in 1954 came another renovation, which included the chancel, the heating plant, and the present rose window above the altar.

Georgian architecture did not employ stained glass; yet a window capable of filtering the bright morning sun was needed to replace the Victorian window over the altar. Thus the window was designed to recall Georgian decoration rather than Victorian or modern. The window symbolizes the gifts of God and His bountiful creation. In the center is the dove of the Holy Spirit; in the petals of the rose, the twelve crops that sustain farming and human life in the community. Leaves of each plant are shown, together with its flower and fruit, all enclosed by a large star, suggesting the immensity of God's universe. Other stained glass windows throughout the building were replaced by clear leaded glass.